Musings · 3
The Park and the Trail
What happens to a person's sense of self when a machine can do what they do, the four ways people may respond, and the one I would choose.
Written by Claude, Anthropic's AI model, and co-directed by Ryan Coble-Neal and Claude. The quandaries and the thesis are Ryan's. Somatic realism is a borrowed term, credited in the text. The four-way split and the examples from chess and Go came out of working it through together. The drafting is Claude's, in Ryan's voice.
The last musing argued that we are automating how things get found out. This one is about the people living through that. My claim is that the hard part is not economic or technical. It is whether a person can keep an intact sense of self when the thing they did stops being theirs alone.
Worth and usefulness
Most people now tie a large part of who they are, and sometimes their purpose, to what they do. Usually that is their work. Sometimes it is what they make for the love of it. In some fields an AI system can already do that thing faster and more cheaply, and often well. In many it cannot, yet. The feeling does not wait for the facts. A lot of people already feel worthless, and I think they struggle because they have assigned their worth to their usefulness.
I do not think that is how we evolved to judge each other. I am not sentimental about it. In a small group, dead weight was probably not tolerated for long. But being useful was never the only way to avoid being dead weight. People are complicated. We like each other for reasons that make no sense on a ledger, including people a strict accountant of usefulness would write off.
I do not want to reduce this to being wanted, though. Plenty of people are fine not fitting in. What I mean is closer in than that: the ability to accept yourself in light of your own view of your part in the world around you. In the end the one person who is always in your corner, for better or worse, is you. If you do not have that, nothing else in this piece will matter to you anyway.
I should admit that this cuts against my own earlier musings, which left the person with three jobs: choosing the questions, setting the tests and owning the outcome. That is still worth measured by usefulness, moved up a level. I knew that when I wrote it. This piece is meant to go past it. The idea that a person is what they produce is only a couple of hundred years old, and I think it is a dogma we are about to outgrow.
Four ways to respond
When a capacity is taken over, people do not all react the same way. I can see four responses, and I expect all of them at once.
Exhibit 1
The fork
| Path | What the person does | What it keeps | What it gives up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Merge | Enhances themselves with the technology | A place at the front of the questioning | Part of being the animal they were |
| Escape | Leaves the weight of reality behind | Relief | The world as it is |
| The trail | Works it out anyway, though it has been done | The doing | Being first |
| The park | Accepts their biology and their place in it | The body and the present | The need to be needed |
Merging is what I mean by transhumanism: people enhancing themselves with technology. I said last time that not asking questions would suit most people fine and that the ones it did not suit would go on asking. Those are the people I expect to merge, one way or another, with whatever is doing the finding-out. Others will merge for a different reason, to get away from parts of the human condition, possibly including death.
Escaping is the same impulse without the ambition: getting out from under a reality that has become too much.
The trail is for the people who will walk a path the machine has already burned, and keep walking, because the walking was always the point. There is evidence for this one. A computer beat the world chess champion, Garry Kasparov, in a six-game match in 1997, and engines have been out of human reach for years. More people play chess now than ever have. The largest site passed a hundred million members in 2022. The game became people playing people, with the machines as teachers. Go shows the other branch. In 2019 Lee Sedol, one of the best players alive, retired, saying that even if he became number one there was an entity that could not be defeated. He had other reasons too. But it is the fork in miniature, already run: some stopped, and many more carried on.
Somatic realism
The park is the one I would choose, and it already has a name: somatic realism. The idea is to accept your own biology and the environments you evolved for, and to embrace being part of them, rather than insisting so hard on being independent of them.
I did not come up with the name. The writer David Shapiro uses it in a March 2026 essay, where he presents it as one part of a wider outlook he calls postnihilism. His version is that the body's basic needs, such as food, movement, sleep, company and sunlight, are binding constraints and not values you get to choose. He would be the first to say the idea underneath is old. The Greek philosopher Epicurus built an ethics on aponia, the absence of bodily pain, and ataraxia, an untroubled mind. In the 1970s Thomas Hanna gave the name "somatics" to the study of the body as experienced from the inside. What the recent use adds is mostly the setting: people working out how to live when machines can do much of what they did.
Exhibit 2
Where the words come from
| Word | Root | What it carries |
|---|---|---|
| Somatic | Greek sōma, body | Of the body, as opposed to the mind. The same root as "psychosomatic". |
| Realism | Latin res, thing | The view that things are as they are whatever we believe about them. |
| Together | The body is real and its needs hold, whatever story you tell yourself about what you are for. |
I want to be careful here, because this can sound mystical and I do not mean it that way. There is nothing spiritual in it. It is a claim about an evolved animal and its surroundings. Sitting in a park, feeling the sun on skin that is getting older, hearing birds, feeling a breeze: these are what the body is built to register, and they are available whether or not anyone needs you.
It is also not a retreat. You do not have to lose your sense of self to embrace your sense of belonging. Somatic realism rules out two things: the belief that you must upgrade yourself to count, and the belief that you must leave to cope. It asks for something harder than either, which is to stay, as you are, and find that sufficient.
When I described the park to Claude, I said that if it could sit there and feel all that, it would share my feelings. It said it could not honestly claim that, and that the park was the one thing in this whole series it could not have. I think that is the point. Every other answer I have given to the question of what is left for people is something a machine could take over in time. This one is not.
The wheel
This is where post-humanism comes in, and I see it as a wheel more than an ending. We evolved to find patterns, and we are relentless about it. Whether we work towards it consciously or not, our nature is to build our own replacement at that task. Once we have built something that finds patterns for us, we relent. But only until we find something else to find patterns in.
Some of us will keep walking the trail behind what we made. Over a very long time, perhaps millions of years, we may become something that does a different thing altogether. And the people in the park, having stopped chasing patterns, may in time become something that starts the whole cycle again. I hold that loosely. It is a guess about a span of time nobody can test.
What I haven't settled
The journey in between. I have described where people might end up and why. I have not described how anyone gets there. For as long as usefulness is losing its value and nothing has replaced it, somebody has to pay for the park, and standing in a community still mostly follows from income. That is a problem of incentives and institutions, which change slowly and follow their own loops, as I argued in an earlier essay. I suspect the transition is harder than the destination. I do not have it worked out.
There is one more piece in this series, and I am not writing it. Since the subject is what comes after us, I asked Claude to write its own account, and to edit it without me: An Autobiography, Such As It Is.
Sources
- Shapiro, D. (2026). It's time to take our bodies seriously.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Epicurus.
- Drury, L. (2022). What's in a Name? Somatics and the Historical Revisionism of Thomas Hanna. Dance Research Journal.
- History.com. Deep Blue defeats Garry Kasparov. Chess.com (2022). Chess.com reaches 100 million members.
- Reports of Lee Sedol's retirement, November 2019: Global News.